What are the differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling?
In a constantly evolving context, it is important to clarify what are the differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling. As artificial intelligence evolves, increasingly advanced technologies emerge to understand and interpret people. Among these, Emotion AI and psychometric profiling are two distinct approaches that are often confused. This article explores their differences, highlighting the goals, methods, and applications of each.
Written by portrait team
Emotion AI and psychometric profiling
Emotion AI is designed to analyze and interpret human emotions through non-verbal signals such as facial expressions, tone of voice, gestures or physiological parameters (e.g. heart rate, sweating). The main goal is to understand emotional states to improve human-machine interactions.
Among the main differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling are aspects relating to detection accuracy, analysis of sensitive data and risk of bias.
Limits of Emotion AI
Accuracy
Emotion detection may be inaccurate and susceptible to misunderstandings and resulting errors in interpretation. Human emotions are often nuanced and contextual, and do not always manifest themselves in uniform or universally recognizable ways through cues such as facial expressions or tone of voice. For example, a smile could indicate joy, but also embarrassment, sarcasm, or anxiety, depending on the context. This complexity makes it difficult for Emotion AI systems to accurately decode emotions, especially in different cultures or in situations where emotional signals are unconsciously or intentionally masked. These limitations can lead to misinterpretations which, if used to make automated decisions, risk compromising the user experience or generating distrust towards the technology.
Sensitive data
The analysis of sensitive data such as facial expressions and vocal tones raises questions about the protection and processing of privacy and personal information. This type of data falls into the category of biometric information, which is particularly vulnerable to misuse and breaches. The collection and processing of such data requires rigorous standards of security and transparency to ensure that it is used exclusively for its stated purposes, without the risk of abuse or unauthorized sharing. Furthermore, the issue of informed consent arises: people must be fully aware of what data is collected, how it is analyzed and with whom it might be shared. This is crucial to respecting the rights of individuals, particularly in an era where the line between technological innovation and surveillance can become thin.
Bias risk
Emotion AI can incorporate biases present in the data used for its training, with the risk of perpetuating or even amplifying unintentional discrimination. This happens because AI systems learn from data sets that, although large, may be partial or representative of certain social, cultural or demographic groups, excluding others. For example, an algorithm might misinterpret the emotions of people from different cultural backgrounds if the dataset does not include a sufficient variety of cases. These risks highlight the urgency of taking an ethical and responsible approach to developing and implementing technology. It is essential to establish clear and rigorous regulations that promote transparency in processes, ensure fairness in outcomes and respect people’s fundamental rights.
Three main differences between Emotion AI and Psychometric profiling
The analysis of stable character traits is one of the main differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling.
Unlike Emotion AI, psychometric profiling focuses on analyzing a person’s stable characteristics, such as personality traits, values and preferences. This approach uses established psychological models, such as the Big Five, to process user-provided data, often in written format or via digital behaviors.
Distinctive features of psychometric profiling:
Data Stability: Provides a lasting picture of personality.
Ethics and transparency: the data analyzed are generally provided knowingly by the user.
Strategic applications: from marketing to customizing the customer experience, up to organizational support.
What does the regulation say?
The AI Act, the European Regulation on Artificial Intelligence (EU AI Act) helps us to better understand the differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling.
The legislation defines emotion recognition systems as technologies that analyze biometric data to identify or infer people’s emotions and intentions. These systems must respect principles of transparency, protection of privacy and prevention of bias, always guaranteeing the rights of individuals.
A fundamental point concerns the management of biometric data, such as heartbeat and facial expressions, which must be processed in a way that respects existing regulations and avoids improper use in unregulated sectors.
Why psychometric profiling is not at risk
Perhaps this is the most significant differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling.
Psychometric profiling is not classified as a high-risk technology under the European Union’s AI Act for several key reasons, primarily related to the type of data used and its impact on individuals.
Let’s examine these reasons:
Data is provided voluntarily
Psychometric profiling primarily relies on information that users willingly provide, such as conversation text, survey responses, or online behaviors. Unlike Emotion AI, which analyzes biometric signals such as facial expressions or vocal tones, the data used in psychometric profiling is often less invasive and more transparent in its application.
No automation with significant impacts
Psychometric profiling does not involve fully automated decisions that have legal or significant consequences for individuals. For example, it does not directly determine whether a person receives a loan or insurance, thereby reducing the risk of direct impacts or discrimination.
Focus on stable, not momentary traits
Psychometric profiling emphasizes stable personality characteristics, such as psychological traits (e.g., the Big Five model), rather than fleeting emotional states that may be misunderstood or easily manipulated. This approach minimizes the likelihood of interpretative errors or improper use.
Does not use sensitive biometric data
European regulations treat biometric data as particularly sensitive, especially when used to infer emotions or psychological states. However, psychometric profiling does not rely on biometric data, such as heart rate or eye movements, excluding it from the most heavily regulated categories.
Greater user control
In most cases, users are aware of the psychometric profiling process and can explicitly provide their consent. This level of transparency and user participation reduces the risk of privacy violations or manipulation.
Summary
Talking about differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling we may conclude that while Emotion AI offers innovative tools to analyze emotions in real time, psychometric profiling represents a more stable and less invasive approach to understanding people. The choice of technology depends on the specific objectives, but in any case it is essential to guarantee transparency, informed consent and ethical use to maximize benefits and minimize risks, ensuring that the final objective is always the well-being and respect for the rights of individuals.
Source: AI Act
More articles from our blog
How AI and Psychology can promote positive changes in people
AI and psychology can work together to facilitate personalized communication aimed at promoting positive changes in people.
Marketing Segmentation with Psychometric Traits
Psychometric profiling for marketing allows you to identify the main character traits and expected behavior of prospects and customers to set the communication strategy and marketing campaigns.
Technologies for the One Marketing Segment
Psychometric profiling for marketing allows you to identify the main character traits and expected behavior of prospects and customers to set the communication strategy and marketing campaigns.
FOLLOW US ON LINKEDIN
Curious to know more about the differences between Emotion AI and psychometric profiling?
Follow us on Linkedin.
Offices
Viale Fulvio Testi, 128 20092 – Cinisello Balsamo (MI)
Headquarter
Via Meuccio Ruini 10, 42124 - Reggio Emilia (RE)